Under the strict interpretation of fasting rules, a violation occurs when a person consciously and voluntarily refuses the prescribed restrictions, resorting to refined or "luxurious" food options, which contradicts the spirit and goals of the fasting practice.

Strict Fasting Practices: Rule Violations and Valid Exemptions

Under the strict interpretation of fasting rules, a violation occurs when a person consciously and voluntarily refuses the prescribed restrictions, resorting to refined or "luxurious" food options, which contradicts the spirit and goals of the fasting practice. For example, the author from file link txt notes:
"And those who boldly and voluntarily break the fasting rule are called 'as enemies of the Cross of Christ: their god is their stomach, and their glory is in disgrace'" (source: link txt).
This indicates that a violation is considered significant when a desire for new pleasures replaces moderation and traditional norms are neglected.

Regarding the conditions of observance, canonical directives specify that the full strictness of the fast applies to those who are physically capable of adhering to the established boundaries. As emphasized in the teachings, healthy individuals are prescribed strict fasting, while leniencies apply to children, the sick, and the elderly. In document link txt, it states:
"The rules of fasting have always been obligatory primarily for the healthy members of the Church. Children, the sick, and the elderly, who cannot maintain a complete fast according to the Rule, do not lose the maternal kindness of the Holy Church" (source: link txt).
Thus, the conditions for observing the fast are determined not only by canonical norms but also by the health status of the fasting individual. Consequently, a violation can be interpreted in different ways: a deliberate deviation from strict rules is viewed as a violation, whereas temporary exemptions for valid reasons (such as weakness or illness) are permitted and do not incur condemnation.

Supporting citation(s):
"And those who boldly and voluntarily break the fasting rule are called 'as enemies of the Cross of Christ: their god is their stomach, and their glory is in disgrace'" (source: link txt).

"The rules of fasting have always been obligatory primarily for the healthy members of the Church. Children, the sick, and the elderly, who cannot maintain a complete fast according to the Rule, do not lose the maternal kindness of the Holy Church" (source: link txt).