Belief in Life’s Meaning vs. Life’s Purpose: A Comparative Perspective
Belief in the meaning of life and belief in the purpose of life differ in their emphasis: the first focuses on what exactly gives existence profound significance, while the second centers on the search for a specific, ultimate goal to which a person aspires.1. Belief in the meaning of life implies perceiving life as a process in which the primary focus is on the apprehension of truth, the understanding of oneself, or even a union with some higher principle. For example, as noted in one of the sources, “Religion, which we understand as a comprehensive system of beliefs where the ideas of God and eternal life are central, sees the meaning of life in union with God. Philosophy, ultimately, in the rational apprehension of truth. Science, in the maximum understanding of the world. Naturally, each of these answers requires a broad interpretation” (source: link txt). Here, the meaning of life is seen as something vast and multifaceted, capable of explaining our existence through spiritual, rational, or scientific comprehension of reality.2. Belief in the purpose of life, on the other hand, implies the presence of a defined, ultimate direction around which the entire life is organized. This idea is evident in the view that life is perceived as a hierarchically structured system, where there are main objectives for which everything happens. As stated: “From beginning to end, it is represented as a hierarchy of goals, with some subordinate to others as means. There are goals that are desirable not for their own sake, but for something else—for example, one needs to work in order to eat and drink. But there is also a goal that is desirable in itself. Each of us has something infinitely dear, for the sake of which we live. Every person, consciously or unconsciously, assumes such a goal or value for which life is undeniably worth living. This goal, or in other words, the meaning of life, is an indispensable presupposition, necessarily connected with life as such...” (source: link txt). Here, the emphasis is on the ultimate benchmark that serves as a measure for actions and decisions throughout life.3. Another example of concretizing the purpose can be seen in the statement: “Spiritual advisor. The answer is clear and simple. One must live in order to achieve the best arrangement of one’s immortal soul during earthly life. Eternal life awaits us—and depending on the spiritual state achieved here, our eternal existence will take one form or another. Illuminated by this eternal task, every aspect of earthly life acquires profound meaning down to the smallest detail. In the absence of immortality, even the greatest events are insignificant, because your whole life, in its entirety, is meaningless, and therefore trivial” (source: link txt). In this example, the purpose of life is expressed as the striving to achieve an ideal spiritual state, which becomes the measure of the significance of the entire earthly existence.
Thus, the difference between belief in the meaning of life and belief in the purpose of life lies in the fact that the first concept answers the question “Why do we live?” by interpreting the entirety of being (union, truth, understanding of the world), while the second concept answers the question “What do we live for?” by defining a specific, often ultimate, goal for which the whole life is built. Both approaches can complement each other, but the distinction lies in their orientation: meaning is an understanding of the profound nature of life, while purpose is a specific direction or result toward which one strives.